11 Underrated Hamilton Songs: Songs You Missed

Hey there, fellow music enthusiasts and DJ comrades! It’s TBone here from Level Tunes, diving into the world of musicals, particularly the gem that is “Hamilton.”

Why am I, a DJ, talking about a Broadway show? Because “Hamilton” isn’t just revolutionary theatre; it’s a treasure trove of incredible tunes that often don’t get the spotlight they deserve.

We all know the big hits, but today, I’m excited to share with you my list of 11 underrated “Hamilton” songs that are absolute bangers.

These tracks deserve a special shout-out for their unique blend of storytelling, rhythm, and raw emotion. Whether you’re a die-hard fan or just cruising for some cool new beats, these tracks are sure to add some fresh flavor to your playlist.

Let’s uncover these hidden musical gems together!

Here are the underrated Hamilton songs that you can check out:

List Of Underrated Hamilton Songs

Underrated Hamilton songs in a list format:

1. “Wait for It”

Artist: Leslie Odom Jr.
Album: Hamilton (Original Broadway Cast Recording) – 2015
Record Label: Atlantic Records

“Wait for It,” performed by the incredibly talented Leslie Odom Jr., stands out as a powerful and introspective piece in the “Hamilton” soundtrack. Released in 2015 under Atlantic Records, this song beautifully captures the complex character of Aaron Burr. The compelling lyrics, combined with Odom’s soulful voice, delve into Burr’s inner conflicts and his philosophy of life. I chose this song for its deep emotional resonance and the way it contrasts Hamilton’s relentless ambition with Burr’s more calculated approach. It’s a masterful exploration of character and motive, and its intricate musical composition is a testament to the genius of Lin-Manuel Miranda’s songwriting.

2. “The Room Where It Happens”

Artist: Leslie Odom Jr.
Album: Hamilton (Original Broadway Cast Recording) – 2015
Record Label: Atlantic Records

Leslie Odom Jr. shines again in “The Room Where It Happens,” a track that vividly brings to life the intrigue and political maneuverings of the era. This song, part of the 2015 original cast recording, is a jazz-infused showstopper that highlights the turning point of Burr’s character. What makes this song stand out is its catchy tune and dynamic storytelling, showcasing Miranda’s ability to blend historical narrative with modern musical styles. I find it underrated due to its unique perspective on history, making it more than just a song but a captivating history lesson set to an unforgettable rhythm.

3. “Who Lives, Who Dies, Who Tells Your Story”

Artist: Original Broadway Cast
Album: Hamilton (Original Broadway Cast Recording) – 2015
Record Label: Atlantic Records

This poignant closing number, performed by the entire original Broadway cast, is a reflective and powerful conclusion to the musical. Released in 2015, it’s a song that often gets overshadowed by the more dynamic numbers in the show. However, its narrative significance is immense. It brings the themes of legacy and memory full circle, questioning how history remembers us. I chose this for its emotional depth and the way it seamlessly ties together the storylines, leaving the audience with a profound sense of contemplation about their own legacies.

4. “Dear Theodosia”

Artist: Leslie Odom Jr. & Lin-Manuel Miranda
Album: Hamilton (Original Broadway Cast Recording) – 2015
Record Label: Atlantic Records

A tender and heartfelt lullaby, “Dear Theodosia,” performed by Leslie Odom Jr. and Lin-Manuel Miranda, showcases a softer side to the characters of Burr and Hamilton. Featured in the 2015 album, this song often goes unnoticed amidst the show’s more dramatic numbers. Its simplicity and emotional depth capture the hopes and fears of new fathers in a burgeoning nation. I love this track for its gentle melody and the way it humanizes these historical figures, revealing their vulnerabilities and dreams for their children.

5. “It’s Quiet Uptown”

Artist: Lin-Manuel Miranda & Original Broadway Cast
Album: Hamilton (Original Broadway Cast Recording) – 2015
Record Label: Atlantic Records

In “It’s Quiet Uptown,” we are offered a poignant glimpse into Hamilton and Eliza’s life following a tragic personal loss. From the 2015 original cast recording, this song is a raw and tender portrayal of grief and forgiveness. Its understated elegance is a testament to Miranda’s songwriting prowess, beautifully conveying the theme of finding peace amidst sorrow. I included this song because of its emotional rawness and the way it showcases a different, more introspective side of the narrative, focusing on personal healing and redemption.

6. “Burn”

Artist: Phillipa Soo
Album: Hamilton (Original Broadway Cast Recording) – 2015
Record Label: Atlantic Records

Phillipa Soo delivers a heart-wrenching performance in “Burn,” where Eliza Hamilton responds to her husband’s public infidelity. This powerful ballad from the 2015 soundtrack often gets overshadowed but is a crucial moment in the show. It’s a song of heartbreak and empowerment, showcasing Eliza’s strength and resilience. I find this song incredibly moving for its portrayal of personal betrayal and the complex emotions involved in love and forgiveness. Soo’s performance is breathtaking, making “Burn” a standout track in its raw emotional intensity.

7. “Non-Stop”

Artist: Lin-Manuel Miranda & Original Broadway Cast
Album: Hamilton (Original Broadway Cast Recording) – 2015
Record Label: Atlantic Records

“Non-Stop” is a dynamic and exhilarating finale to the first act of the musical, featuring Lin-Manuel Miranda and the original cast. Released in 2015, it’s a song that brilliantly weaves together multiple narrative threads and character arcs. This track is a showcase of Miranda’s lyrical genius, with its fast-paced rap and intricate rhymes. I admire this song for its energy and how it encapsulates the relentless spirit of Alexander Hamilton, while also setting the stage for the drama of the second act.

8. “Yorktown (The World Turned Upside Down)”

Artist: Original Broadway Cast
Album: Hamilton (Original Broadway Cast Recording) – 2015
Record Label: Atlantic Records

This rousing number, performed by the original Broadway cast, captures the pivotal moment of the Battle of Yorktown. From the 2015 soundtrack, “Yorktown” is an energetic and triumphant celebration of a key American Revolution victory. Its blend of hip-hop and traditional Broadway styles makes it a unique and exhilarating listening experience. I selected this song for its historical significance and the way it conveys the excitement and uncertainty of a nation in the midst of transformation.

9. “One Last Time”

Artist: Christopher Jackson
Album: Hamilton (Original Broadway Cast Recording) – 2015
Record Label: Atlantic Records

Christopher Jackson delivers a powerful performance as George Washington in “One Last Time,” a song that highlights Washington’s decision to step down from the presidency. Included in the 2015 album, this track stands out for its historical relevance and emotional depth. It’s a song that captures the dignity and wisdom of Washington, showcasing a crucial moment in American political history. I appreciate this number for its poignant message about leadership and legacy, as well as Jackson’s commanding vocal performance.

10. “Cabinet Battle #1”

Artist: Lin-Manuel Miranda & Daveed Diggs
Album: Hamilton (Original Broadway Cast Recording) – 2015
Record Label: Atlantic Records

“Cabinet Battle #1,” featuring Lin-Manuel Miranda and Daveed Diggs, is a unique and clever depiction of political debate through rap. Part of the 2015 original cast recording, this track brings to life the ideological clashes between Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson. I’m drawn to this song for its inventive approach to historical narrative, turning a cabinet meeting into a riveting rap battle. It’s a brilliant blend of education and entertainment, making history accessible and engaging.

11. “Stay Alive (Reprise)”

Artist: Original Broadway Cast
Album: Hamilton (Original Broadway Cast Recording) – 2015
Record Label: Atlantic Records

“Stay Alive (Reprise)” is a haunting and emotional piece from the 2015 soundtrack, performed by the original Broadway cast. This track, often overlooked, highlights a tragic moment in the narrative, conveying a deep sense of loss and despair. Its solemn melody and poignant lyrics create a powerful emotional impact. I chose this song for its ability to evoke a profound sense of empathy and sorrow, beautifully capturing the human cost of the events depicted in the musical.

Fun Facts: Underrated Hamilton Songs

“Wait for It”

• Fact 1: “Wait for It” is often considered the song that best encapsulates the character of Aaron Burr. Lin-Manuel Miranda, the creator of “Hamilton,” has said that this song is one of the best he’s ever written.
• Fact 2: Leslie Odom Jr., who plays Burr, won a Tony Award for Best Actor in a Musical, partly due to his performance of this song. His emotional rendition has been praised for its depth and complexity.

“The Room Where It Happens”

• Fact 1: This song is inspired by a real historical event, the Compromise of 1790, but it adds dramatic flair to the secrecy surrounding the deal. The catchy phrase “The Room Where It Happens” has since been used in political contexts.
• Fact 2: The song blends various musical styles, including jazz and Broadway, reflecting Lin-Manuel Miranda’s diverse musical influences and contributing to the song’s unique sound in the context of a historical musical.

“Who Lives, Who Dies, Who Tells Your Story”

• Fact 1: This song serves as the finale of the musical and reflects on the legacy of Alexander Hamilton. It’s unique as it shifts the focus from Hamilton to Eliza, highlighting her role in preserving Hamilton’s legacy.
• Fact 2: The song includes a moment where Eliza gasps or sighs at the end, a moment that has spurred numerous fan theories and interpretations. Miranda has deliberately left this moment ambiguous, adding to the song’s intrigue.

“Dear Theodosia”

• Fact 1: “Dear Theodosia” is a lullaby sung by both Aaron Burr and Alexander Hamilton to their newborn children. This song stands out as it showcases the softer, more vulnerable sides of these historical figures.
• Fact 2: The song is notable for its simplicity in the musical, differing from the more complex and fast-paced numbers. It provides a moment of calm and introspection in the midst of the revolutionary narrative.

“It’s Quiet Uptown”

• Fact 1: This song is about Alexander Hamilton and his wife Eliza coping with the death of their son, Philip. It’s considered one of the most emotionally impactful songs in the musical.
• Fact 2: The song has been praised for its honest portrayal of grief and forgiveness, and many fans have shared that it brings them to tears due to its raw emotional power.

“Burn”

• Fact 1: “Burn” is Eliza Hamilton’s solo number, where she reacts to her husband’s affair. This song is significant as it gives Eliza a powerful voice and agency, showcasing her emotions and strength.
• Fact 2: The song’s title, “Burn,” refers to Eliza burning Hamilton’s letters, a historical fact that has been confirmed through historical documents. This act symbolizes her anger and heartbreak.

“Non-Stop”

• Fact 1: “Non-Stop” is the final song of Act One and is a culmination of all the musical themes and motifs introduced in the first half of the show. It showcases Miranda’s skill in weaving together multiple storylines and musical styles.
• Fact 2: The song includes a foreshadowing of the duel between Hamilton and Burr, setting up the tension that will be explored in the second act of the musical.

“Yorktown (The World Turned Upside Down)”

• Fact 1: The title and chorus of the song reference the historical anecdote that the British army band played the tune “The World Turned Upside Down” when they surrendered at Yorktown.
• Fact 2: This song is a favorite among fans for its high energy and triumphant tone, celebrating a pivotal moment in American history with a modern musical twist.

“One Last Time”

• Fact 1: “One Last Time” is based on George Washington’s real Farewell Address. The song incorporates actual lines from the address, showcasing the musical’s commitment to historical accuracy.
• Fact 2: Christopher Jackson, who plays Washington, has been praised for his performance, which captures the gravitas and dignity of the first American president.

“Cabinet Battle #1”

• Fact 1: This song presents a political debate as a rap battle, a unique and modern interpretation of historical events. It’s inspired by real debates between Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson.
• Fact 2: The concept of a cabinet meeting as a rap battle was praised for its creativity and effectiveness in making historical political debates engaging and accessible to a modern audience.

“Stay Alive (Reprise)”

• Fact 1: This reprise is emotionally charged, depicting the aftermath of Philip Hamilton’s death in a duel. It’s a stark contrast to the earlier song “Stay Alive,” which is more upbeat and focuses on survival in war.

And there you have it, music lovers and Hamilton fans! A deep dive into some of the most underrated gems from a musical masterpiece. These songs, each unique and powerful, remind us why “Hamilton” is not just a show, but a cultural phenomenon. Keep grooving to the rhythm of history!

Thanks for reading.

TBone