17 Best Songs From Buffy the Vampire Slayer: Buffy’s Gems

Ready to slay with rhythm? Buffy the Vampire Slayer didn’t just drive stakes through hearts, but also delivered captivating tunes.

From haunting melodies to ‘Once More, With Feeling’s’ musical extravaganza, Buffy’s soundtrack is the soul of Sunnydale. Join us as we unveil the 17 best songs that made us cheer, cry, and everything in between.

Here are the best songs from Buffy the Vampire Slayer that you can check out:

List Of Best Songs From Buffy the Vampire Slayer

Best songs from Buffy the Vampire Slayer in a list format:

1. Buffy The Vampire Slayer Theme – Nerf Herder

Nerf Herder’s punchy punk rock riff is what greets you in every episode of Buffy. This is not just a theme song, it’s a call to arms! It’s part of the album “Buffy the Vampire Slayer: The Album”.

2. Full of Grace – Sarah McLachlan

Aching and poignant, Sarah McLachlan’s “Full of Grace” appeared in the Season 2 finale. It’s heart-wrenching and encapsulates the sorrowful mood. You can find it on her album “Surfacing”.

3. Wild Horses – The Sundays

This ethereal cover of The Rolling Stones’ classic is like a breath of fresh air. It features in season 3 and graces The Sundays’ album “Blind”.

4. I Quit – Hepburn

Oozing girl power, “I Quit” by Hepburn is a feisty track from Season 3. Put it on and dance out frustrations! It’s on their self-titled album “Hepburn”.

5. Goodbye to You – Michelle Branch

Heard in Season 6, Michelle Branch’s “Goodbye to You” is a bittersweet breakup anthem that hits all the right chords. The song is from her album “The Spirit Room”.

6. Stupid Thing – Nickel

This pop-rock ditty by Nickel is featured in Season 4. It’s catchy and endearing, and can be found on their album “Stupid Thing”.

7. Blue – Angie Hart

Angie Hart’s hauntingly beautiful voice in “Blue” seeped into our souls in Season 7. This gem is part of the “Buffy the Vampire Slayer: Radio Sunnydale” album.

8. Going Through The Motions – Sarah Michelle Gellar

Straight from the musical episode, this song showcases Buffy’s turmoil with a catchy beat. It’s part of the “Once More, with Feeling” album.

9. Rest In Peace – James Marsters

Spike’s sardonic yet heartfelt song in the musical episode is a hit. James Marsters totally rocks it. Find it on “Once More, with Feeling”.

10. Sugar Water – Cibo Matto

Quirky and hypnotic, “Sugar Water” by Cibo Matto adds flavor to Season 2. It’s part of the band’s “Viva! La Woman” album.

11. Virgin State of Mind – K’s Choice

Deep and reflective, this song from Season 3 is a mood. It’s by K’s Choice and can be found on “Buffy the Vampire Slayer: The Album”.

12. Pavlov’s Bell – Aimee Mann

In Season 7, Aimee Mann’s “Pavlov’s Bell” is indie rock at its finest. It’s from her “Lost in Space” album.

13. Key – Devics

Hauntingly atmospheric, Devics’ “Key” featured in Season 5. You can find it on their album “My Beautiful Sinking Ship”.

14. Prayer of St. Francis – Sarah McLachlan

This serene track gives Season 7 a gentle touch. By Sarah McLachlan, it’s part of the album “Rarities, B-Sides and Other Stuff Volume 2”.

15. I Can’t Take My Eyes Off You – Melanie Doane

A sweet love song by Melanie Doane, it graced Season 4 and can be found on the album “Adam’s Rib”.

16. Ballad for Dead Friends – Dashboard Prophets

Dark and brooding, this Dashboard Prophets’ song from Season 1 is on “Buffy the Vampire Slayer: The Album”.

17. Black Cat Bone – Laika

An eerie yet funky number by Laika, “Black Cat Bone” is featured in Season 6. You’ll find it on their “Good Looking Blues” album.

Fun Facts: Best Tracks From Buffy the Vampire Slayer

Full of Grace – Sarah McLachlan

Fun Fact: Sarah McLachlan’s “Full of Grace” is often referred to as the “Buffy/Angel breakup song” by fans. It’s become synonymous with the heart-wrenching moment when Buffy has to say goodbye to Angel in the Season 2 finale. The song and scene together have left an indelible mark on the hearts of fans.

Buffy The Vampire Slayer Theme – Nerf Herder

Fun Fact: The theme song was actually a last-minute addition! The original theme didn’t have the energy the creators wanted. Nerf Herder, who described themselves as nerds and huge fans of the show, submitted their piece, and it was chosen as the new theme. And what a pick it was!

Going Through The Motions – Sarah Michelle Gellar

Fun Fact: “Going Through The Motions” was the opening number in the famous musical episode “Once More, with Feeling” in Season 6. The cast of Buffy performed the songs themselves and Sarah Michelle Gellar was initially nervous about singing. However, she nailed her performance and this song became one of the fan favorites!

Rest In Peace – James Marsters

Fun Fact: James Marsters, who played Spike, has said that “Rest In Peace” was an incredibly personal song for him. The writer and director of the episode, Joss Whedon, told him that the song was about every relationship he had ever been in. That struck a chord with Marsters, and he put his all into the performance.

Sugar Water – Cibo Matto

Fun Fact: “Sugar Water” was performed live by Cibo Matto in The Bronze, a popular nightclub in the show. What’s cool is that the band’s lead singer, Miho Hatori, is also known for being the original voice of Noodle, a member of the virtual band Gorillaz!

Pavlov’s Bell – Aimee Mann

Fun Fact: Aimee Mann is one of the few artists who made a cameo on the show. She performed “Pavlov’s Bell” at The Bronze. After her performance in the episode, she even had a speaking line, where she stated, “Man, I hate playing vampire towns.”

That’s a wrap, fellow Buffy enthusiasts and music lovers! Thanks for jamming through this supernatural playlist with us. May these tracks bring back memories and slay your hearts. Happy listening! 🎶🖤

Thanks for reading.

TBone