17 Underrated Billy Joel Songs: The Tracks You Didn’t Know

Hey there, fellow music enthusiasts! It’s TBone from Level Tunes, spinning the decks and always on the hunt for hidden gems in the world of music.

Lately, I’ve been on a Billy Joel binge, and man, there’s so much more to him than just “Piano Man” and “Uptown Girl”.

As a DJ and a die-hard music lover, I’ve realized that many of his tracks are criminally underrated and deserve their moment in the spotlight.

So, I’ve curated a list of 17 Billy Joel songs that often fly under the radar but have the power to move you, surprise you, and even make you dance.

Here are the underrated Billy Joel songs that you can check out:

List Of Underrated Billy Joel Songs

Underrated Billy Joel songs in a list format:

1. Summer, Highland Falls

Album: Turnstiles (1976)
Label: Columbia Records

This track is a gem from Billy’s 1976 “Turnstiles” album. The harmonious intertwining of major and minor tones reflects the ups and downs of life. One could argue that the song’s poetic lyrics and Joel’s emotive voice convey the tumultuous nature of human relationships. I chose this because it showcases Joel’s ability to capture complex emotions with simplicity.

2. Vienna

Album: The Stranger (1977)
Label: Columbia Records

“Vienna” is a gentle reminder that life isn’t always a race. Tucked away in “The Stranger,” this masterpiece often gets overshadowed by heavyweights like “Moving Out”. Its message resonates deeply, emphasizing the importance of pacing oneself. The beautiful piano work combined with the heartwarming lyrics makes this song an essential listen.

3. Rosalinda’s Eyes

Album: 52nd Street (1978)
Label: Columbia Records

Inspired by Joel’s mother, this heartwarming tribute has a Latin flair that’s irresistibly catchy. The rich percussion, horn sections, and Joel’s passionate vocals make it stand out. I adore it for its warmth and the way it honors the powerful women in our lives.

4. All for Leyna

Album: Glass Houses (1980)
Label: Columbia Records

This rock-driven number demonstrates Joel’s versatility. Its energetic piano lines and catchy chorus ensure it remains memorable. “All for Leyna” paints a picture of infatuation’s intensity, making it relatable for anyone who’s ever been head-over-heels in love.

5. Surprises

Album: The Nylon Curtain (1982)
Label: Columbia Records

I selected “Surprises” for its introspective lyrics. Joel delves deep into personal growth and the journey of self-discovery. Its synthesis of electronica hints reveals how Joel always remained contemporary, even when venturing into new territories.

6. Laura

Album: The Nylon Curtain (1982)
Label: Columbia Records

This track showcases Joel’s prowess in storytelling. The song chronicles a turbulent relationship, capturing the push and pull dynamic. Its layered production and meaningful lyrics deserve more recognition, hence its spot on this list.

7. Sleeping with the Television On

Album: Glass Houses (1980)
Label: Columbia Records

This energetic pop-rock track is an underrated delight. Its lyrics depict the challenges of modern romance, making it both fun and thought-provoking. I love it for its effervescence and catchy chorus.

8. The Great Wall of China

Album: River of Dreams (1993)
Label: Columbia Records

A testament to broken friendships, this song’s heartfelt lyrics and powerful vocals make it resonate deeply. Its inclusion here underscores Joel’s enduring ability to capture universal human experiences.

9. Careless Talk

Album: An Innocent Man (1983)
Label: Columbia Records

With its doo-wop vibes, this track transports listeners back to the ’50s. Its message about the dangers of gossip remains timeless, and I appreciate its retro charm juxtaposed with a modern message.

10. A Room of Our Own

Album: The Nylon Curtain (1982)
Label: Columbia Records

This song is pure fun, reflecting the need for personal space in relationships. The upbeat tempo and relatable message make it an underrated standout for me.

11. Code of Silence

Album: The Bridge (1986)
Label: Columbia Records

Featuring Cyndi Lauper on backing vocals, this track delves into the difficulties of communication. Its strong ’80s vibes and synth elements make it an era-defining piece worth revisiting.

12. Half a Mile Away

Album: 52nd Street (1978)
Label: Columbia Records

This jazzy number showcases Joel’s talent for blending genres. Its energetic horns and upbeat tempo make it a hidden gem in his discography.

13. Running on Ice

Album: The Bridge (1986)
Label: Columbia Records

A testament to the frenetic pace of modern life, this track’s rapid piano lines mirror its message perfectly. I admire its energy and the way it captures life’s chaos.

14. She’s Right on Time

Album: The Nylon Curtain (1982)
Label: Columbia Records

This festive number celebrates love’s timely arrivals. Its heartwarming message and seasonally appropriate charm make it an underrated classic in my books.

15. Stiletto

Album: 52nd Street (1978)
Label: Columbia Records

A song about the dangers of a vindictive lover, its metaphorical lyrics and bluesy vibes showcase Joel’s ability to craft unique tales. Its edgy nature earns it a spot on this list.

16. This Night

Album: An Innocent Man (1983)
Label: Columbia Records

A nod to the doo-wop era, this ballad is pure romance. Its dreamy chorus, with references to Beethoven’s “Pathétique,” showcases Joel’s deep appreciation for classical influences.

17. Two Thousand Years

Album: River of Dreams (1993)
Label: Columbia Records

This anthemic track provides a sweeping look at human history and our place in it. Its grandeur and contemplative message make it a fitting end to this list.

Fun Facts: Underrated Billy Joel Songs

1. Summer, Highland Falls

• Billy Joel once stated in an interview that the song represents the bipolar nature of humans. The highs and lows, the good and the bad – it’s about the duality of our nature, and this song captures that sentiment perfectly.

2. Vienna

• “Vienna” was inspired by a visit to the European city where Billy’s father lived. Joel felt the slower pace of life there contrasted sharply with the hectic rhythm of New York. The song’s message is about taking life at your own pace and enjoying every moment.

3. Rosalinda’s Eyes

• As mentioned earlier, this song is a tribute to Billy Joel’s mother, Rosalinda. The Latin rhythm was used to honor her Cuban roots, and it remains a heartwarming homage to all mothers and their unwavering love.

6. Laura

• The song isn’t about any particular person named Laura. Instead, it’s a composite of several people Billy knew. However, the name “Laura” was used because it fit well melodically.

8. The Great Wall of China

• The lyrics “We could have been standing on the Great Wall of China” speak to missed opportunities and chances not taken. This song is believed by many to be a nod to Joel’s former manager, whom he had a falling out with over financial issues.

11. Code of Silence

• The collaboration with Cyndi Lauper isn’t just in the song itself. Lauper also co-wrote this track with Billy Joel. Their combined genius resulted in a song that explores the difficulties of keeping secrets and the importance of open communication.

13. Running on Ice

• Joel likened the song’s rhythm and urgency to the music of The Police, a prominent band in the ’80s. The fast-paced piano mimics the feeling of running, adding to the song’s sense of urgency.

15. Stiletto

• In concerts, Joel often introduced this song by joking about how some relationships are harmful, likening them to being repeatedly stabbed with a stiletto heel. It’s his quirky take on acknowledging the pain with a dose of humor.

16. This Night

• Billy Joel is a known fan of classical music, and in “This Night”, he borrows the melody from Beethoven’s “Pathétique” Sonata. It’s a brilliant blend of pop and classical, showcasing his versatility.

There you have it, folks! Billy Joel’s tunes are a treasure trove of stories, emotions, and musical genius. As you dive into these lesser-known tracks, may you find new rhythms to dance to and lyrics to ponder. Keep the music alive and the turntable spinning!

Thanks for reading.

TBone